About Us / Reviews

Fresh Local Dairy Products…

We are a single-family farm that has been producing quality milk for the wholesale market since 1993, milking approximately 58 cows year-round. As our family has grown, we have been looking for opportunities to grow our business.

After many years of studying and research we have committed to putting in a dairy processing plant and producing a local brand of ice cream and bottled milk, along with yogurts and drinkable yogurts.

A cup of Old Mill Creamery ice cream topped with berry sauce and chocolate pieces, with more chocolate pieces scattered on a light wooden surface.

A cup of vanilla ice cream with pineapple chunks in a black Old Mill Creamery branded container on a wooden surface.

A cup of vanilla ice cream topped with two large cookies, surrounded by broken cookie pieces on a white surface. The cup is labeled “Old Mill Creamery Homemade Ice Cream.”.

A hot beverage in a white paper cup topped with whipped cream, chocolate chunks, and pink peppermint pieces, with a cardboard sleeve around the cup.

What is A2A2 Milk?

Close

Q

Reviews

4.9 Over 272 Reviews

Write a Review

Chris Barsis 1 month ago

Great little mom and pop small business, delicious whole milk ice cream. Recommended!

...

Harold Dunkle 1 month ago

...

James Dolezal 2 months ago

Best ice cream I’ve had in my life.

...

Duane Schmader 2 months ago

The best ice cream in the area. I love many of my local ice cream places! However, anytime I take a spoonful and taste it, I immediately know this is my favorite in the area.

...

Kurt Ilgen 2 months ago