Click to See Our Weekly Specials

Click to See Our Weekly Specials

The Farm Kitchen Deli specials – July 21 – 26

Mesquite Smoked Turkey Breast – $4.99 lb
Colby Swiss Swirl Cheese – $3.99 lb
Close
Q
Click to See Our Catalog
Logo for "The Farmers' Creamery" featuring silhouettes of cows and calves standing on a hill above the business name in cursive text.

About Us / Reviews

Ice Cream, Baked Goods, & Other Dairy Products at Their Best…

The Farmer’s Creamery is Michigan’s new favorite dairy and farm kitchen destination. Owned and operated by local Amish in the Mio area, they offer a full range of dairy items from 100% grass-fed cows, without antibiotics and no added hormones.

Their in-store bakery offers fresh baked breads, pies, cookies, and sweet rolls. The full service deli features Walnut Creek meats and cheeses, with made-to-order breakfast & lunch sandwiches.

Shop their gourmet food shop for Tried & True Granola, Pure Michigan syrups & honey, and a wide selection of jams & preserves. Buy some gifts from the home décor and living space accessory nook.

Reviews
4.8 Over 428 Reviews
Write a Review
google
Liv Enlearn 1 week ago
My sister is being shunned because of this store.
We had a large happy family and we used to think all of us were decent people but then we bought the amazing, huge, heavenly deli sandwiches (and the maple nut and caramel sweet rolls!) at The Farmer’s Creamery and after we went…
My sister admitted doesn’t like them. She said Subway is better.
As you can imagine there was an uproar. Of course we were disturbed. We gave her another chance though and dragged her back to Mio and insisted she try the burgers from the Creamery, because those are even *better* than their deli sandwiches!
But my sister claimed that McDonald’s tastes better.
Obviously we have to kick her out of our family. It’s sad, but it isn't like we can sit across from her at the dinner table at Christmas now that we know she believes this way. Please don’t blame my parents; they raised her the best they could. It’s not their fault that her food preferences are only mildly less alarming than Jeffrey Dahmer’s. We’ve been interrogating her ever since and we discovered that she also hates cheesecake, carrot cake, raisins, walnuts, Oreos, pecan pie (we swear, we had no idea she is such a weirdo) and some flavors of Skittles, so while this store has been an incredible find, it’s also opened up a can of worms in our poor family. You’ve been warned.
...
google
Debra Cramer 2 months ago
Overpriced. A dozen eggs were $5.99 and price per pound of meat and cheeses also quite high. For a farmer direct type outlet, I usually find prices more reasonable. It has a welcoming atmosphere, very clean and well organized with workers singing hymns as they worked. Cherry pie was reasonably priced, but unfortunately not very good and the filling was cloudy, not sure why. I did enjoy the pecan rolls that were covered with fresh pecan pieces. Also only cash and checks accepted.
...
google
Shane Mackey 2 months ago
ALMOST $40 FOR 3 LOAVES OF MOLDY BREAD. Do NOT ask for any special orders here. I ordered three loaves of spelt bread to be picked up when they called me the following Friday. They did not call me until Friday evening at approximately 8:00 p.m. hours after they had closed. Because they did not call me when they promised they would, my work obligations prevented me from making it back to the store (which is 40 minutes from my house) until the following Friday. When I arrived, I learned that they were charging me $12.19 PER LOAF, AND THE LOAVES WERE COMPLETED MOLDY (see pictures). When I went to pay for the bread, it appeared that the individual working the cash register attempted to conceal the mold rather than address the problem. I should have refused to pay and simply walked out, but who wants to start and argument with the Amish, right? So, I paid for the bread because I ordered it, and, unlike the workers in this store, I am a man of my word. Adding insult to injury, they did not even bake the bread. Rather, they bought it from Swiss Villa LLC, an Amish bakery in Washington Boro, Pennsylvania, and had it shipped here. I then left The Farmer's Creamery and traveled 3.5 miles down the road The Bakery (on Camp 10 Road) and bought fresh bread for $3 a loaf.

I once had a friend tell me that the Amish are scammers (ironically referring to this same community), and I was highly offended that they would make such an accusation. I’ve also read that the Amish are an extremely closed community who could care less for “the English” as they call us. After this experience, I must say that I have to agree. I will never order any special orders from here again, and my entire idealized view of this seemingly idyllic Amish community has been forever changed.
...
google
Megan Gensler 3 months ago
Sooo many bake goods! Visited mio for a tubbing trip and this was a great place to stop by to kill sometime. Many different drinks, bake goods, ice cream, sausage,jams, recipe books, etc.great customer service
...
google
Ty Schroeder 3 months ago
Their milk is way better than store bought and their sandwiches are delicious
...
google
Tony Jaynes 3 months ago
None of it is homemade. All store bought from Gordon's food and there veggie stand
...

Directions / Contact / Hours

Contact Us!

Phone: (989) 826-8666
Address: 50 W Kittle Rd, Mio, MI 48647

Monday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Sunday
Closed

Our Product Catalog

(Click to Expand)

Front exterior view of The Farmers’ Creamery building with signage for dairy and meats; text reads "Product Catalog.
A group of cows graze on green grass under a cloudy sky, with informative text about 100% grass-fed dairy from Michigan farms above them.
Four glass milk bottles labeled as whole milk, chocolate milk, 2% milk, and fat free milk, each with a UPC code, displayed on a white wooden background.
Six glass bottles of milk (whole, 2%, and fat free) are displayed on a wooden background, each labeled with type, size, and UPC code.
Six glass bottles labeled buttermilk, heavy cream, and half & half, each shown in 16 or 32 ounces, arranged in two rows on a wooden background.
Six glass bottles of flavored milk (Chocolate, Moo-Cacino, and Salted Caramel) in 16oz and 32oz sizes, arranged in two rows against a wooden background.
Four 16oz bottles of Stensland's Creamery milk in chocolate, moo-cacino, salted caramel, and whole milk flavors are displayed with their UPC codes on a wood background.
Four bottles of Farmer's Organic yogurt smoothies—raspberry, strawberry, peach, and blueberry—each 16oz, displayed against a white wooden background with product names and UPCs shown.
Six bottles of yogurt smoothies in three flavors—plain, raspberry, and peach—are displayed by The Farmer’s Creamery, showing two sizes for each flavor on a white wooden background.
Six bottles of smoothies and eggnog are arranged in two rows, labeled as strawberry yogurt, blueberry yogurt, and eggnog, each shown in two different sizes with corresponding UPC codes.
Two jars of pure honey, one 16 oz and one 32 oz, with labels and UPC codes, displayed against a white wooden background.
Four vacuum-sealed packs of cheese curds—smoked, hot pepper, chive, and dill—are displayed on a wood-textured background with product names and UPC codes beneath each pack.
Three packages of cheese curds—horseradish, original, and Cajun—are displayed on a wooden background with product names, UPC codes, and a description of the creamery’s pasteurization process.
Four pints of The Farmer’s Creamery ice cream—Strawberry, Black Cherry, Vanilla, and Mint Chocolate Chip—are displayed against a wooden background with UPC codes under each.
Four pints of The Farmers Creamery ice cream are shown: Espresso, Chocolate, Butter Pecan, and Cookies & Cream, each with a green lid and UPC code on a wooden background.
Six glass jars of different fruit jams are displayed against a white wooden background, each labeled with the flavor, product name, and UPC code.
Six jars of jam and apple butter are displayed in two rows, each labeled: strawberry, apricot, strawberry rhubarb, peach, apple butter, and black cherry, with UPCs and weights listed.
Six half-gallon bottles of different lemonade flavors are displayed against a white wooden background, each labeled with flavor, UPC, and "Half Gallon.
Six bottles of flavored lemonade drinks are arranged in two rows against a wooden background, each labeled with flavor, UPC code, and a 16 oz size.
Six bottles of various lemonade flavors are displayed in two rows against a wood-patterned background, each labeled with its name, size, and UPC code.
Two egg cartons on a wooden background: one labeled “Duck Eggs” (half dozen), the other “Grade A Large Brown Eggs” (12 eggs); both show farm-themed packaging and UPC codes.
Cows grazing in a green pasture with trees in the background; below are positive customer testimonials about dairy products, especially chocolate milk.
An informational flyer about A2 milk, detailing its differences from regular milk, potential benefits, and stating it is from Michigan grass-fed cows with no added hormones or antibiotics.
Text that reads "Our Farmers' Pledge" with a list of commitments to ethical animal and land care, no antibiotics or hormones, and providing quality dairy products. Contact info is at the bottom.

NEW Photo Gallery Coming Soon