About Us / Reviews
Ice Cream, Baked Goods, & Other Dairy Products at Their Best…
The Farmer’s Creamery is Michigan’s new favorite dairy and farm kitchen destination. Owned and operated by local Amish in the Mio area, they offer a full range of dairy items from 100% grass-fed cows, without antibiotics and no added hormones.
Their in-store bakery offers fresh baked breads, pies, cookies, and sweet rolls. The full service deli features Walnut Creek meats and cheeses, with made-to-order breakfast & lunch sandwiches.
Shop their gourmet food shop for Tried & True Granola, Pure Michigan syrups & honey, and a wide selection of jams & preserves. Buy some gifts from the home décor and living space accessory nook.
Reviews
Their salted caramel and moochachino milks are the very best for smoothies and adding a little creamy sweetness to my favorite teas. I love that it comes in returnable glass bottles ..reminds me of the milk I grew up with in the best ways.
Great for sweets and fresh bread. Must stop if you’re going by there. The Amish are great cooks. They now also do burgers and sandwiches made as requested. Prices went up but that’s everywhere now. Great ice cream too!
Beautifully stacked sandwiches and the song of an angel choir while shopping. Truly a wonderful experience. All the ladies there are so nice and helpful. I plan to visit as often as possible.
They have a good variety of meats, cheeses and baked goods. They also have a great discount when they mark something down
My sister is being shunned because of this store.
We had a large happy family and we used to think all of us were decent people but then we bought the amazing, huge, heavenly deli sandwiches (and the maple nut and caramel sweet rolls!) at The Farmer’s Creamery and after we went…
My sister admitted doesn’t like them. She said Subway is better.
As you can imagine there was an uproar. Of course we were disturbed. We gave her another chance though and dragged her back to Mio and insisted she try the burgers from the Creamery, because those are even *better* than their deli sandwiches!
But my sister claimed that McDonald’s tastes better.
Obviously we have to kick her out of our family. It’s sad, but it isn't like we can sit across from her at the dinner table at Christmas now that we know she believes this way. Please don’t blame my parents; they raised her the best they could. It’s not their fault that her food preferences are only mildly less alarming than Jeffrey Dahmer’s. We’ve been interrogating her ever since and we discovered that she also hates cheesecake, carrot cake, raisins, walnuts, Oreos, pecan pie (we swear, we had no idea she is such a weirdo) and some flavors of Skittles, so while this store has been an incredible find, it’s also opened up a can of worms in our poor family. You’ve been warned.
We had a large happy family and we used to think all of us were decent people but then we bought the amazing, huge, heavenly deli sandwiches (and the maple nut and caramel sweet rolls!) at The Farmer’s Creamery and after we went…
My sister admitted doesn’t like them. She said Subway is better.
As you can imagine there was an uproar. Of course we were disturbed. We gave her another chance though and dragged her back to Mio and insisted she try the burgers from the Creamery, because those are even *better* than their deli sandwiches!
But my sister claimed that McDonald’s tastes better.
Obviously we have to kick her out of our family. It’s sad, but it isn't like we can sit across from her at the dinner table at Christmas now that we know she believes this way. Please don’t blame my parents; they raised her the best they could. It’s not their fault that her food preferences are only mildly less alarming than Jeffrey Dahmer’s. We’ve been interrogating her ever since and we discovered that she also hates cheesecake, carrot cake, raisins, walnuts, Oreos, pecan pie (we swear, we had no idea she is such a weirdo) and some flavors of Skittles, so while this store has been an incredible find, it’s also opened up a can of worms in our poor family. You’ve been warned.
Overpriced. A dozen eggs were $5.99 and price per pound of meat and cheeses also quite high. For a farmer direct type outlet, I usually find prices more reasonable. It has a welcoming atmosphere, very clean and well organized with workers singing hymns as they worked. Cherry pie was reasonably priced, but unfortunately not very good and the filling was cloudy, not sure why. I did enjoy the pecan rolls that were covered with fresh pecan pieces. Also only cash and checks accepted.
Directions / Contact / Hours
Contact Us!
Phone: (989) 826-8666
Address: 50 W Kittle Rd, Mio, MI 48647
Monday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday
7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday
8:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Sunday
Closed
























